HomeMy WebLinkAboutOrdinance-2007-1393
CITY OF WHEAT RIDGE, COLORADO
INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MEMBER STITES
Council Bill No. 1')-7007
Ordinance No. 1393
AN ORDINANCE ADOPTING A COMPETITIVE CABLE FRANCHISE APPLICATION,
REVIEW AND EVALUATION PROCESS IN CONNECTION WITH ANY FRANCHISE
APPLICATION SUBMITTED PURSUANT TO ~76.41 OF TITLE 47 OF THE CODE OF
FEDERAL REGULATIONS
WHEREAS, On December 20, 2006, the Federal Communications
Commission ("FCC") adopted a new rule, set forth in a Report and Order and
Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that was released March 5, 2007, that
among other things, provides a separate, nonexclusive process for the issuance of
cable franchises for areas currently served by another cable operator (the
"Competitive Franchise Application Rule" or "CFAR"); and
WHEREAS, the CFAR provides that local franchising authorities may require
application information from an applicant for a competitive cable franchise, in
addition to the information set forth in the CFAR; and
WHEREAS, the City of Wheat Ridge (hereinafter, the "City") has determined
that in order to comprehensively evaluate whether or not to grant a competitive
cable franchise, it will require certain information from applicants in addition to the
information required by the CFAR; and
WHEREAS, to ensure compliance with the CFAR, the City additionally seeks
to codify the process for reviewing applications for competitive cable franchises,
and the criteria upon which the final decision of the City will be based; and
WHEREAS, the application requirements and the processes for application
review and determination set forth in this Ordinance are intended to comply with
the new FCC rules.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
WHEAT RIDGE:
-1-
Section 1. The Wheat Ridge Code of Laws is amended by renumbering eXisting
Section 23-1 as Article 1 within Chapter 23, and by the adoption of a new Article
2, entitled "Competitive Cable Franchise Application, Review and Evaluation, " to
read as follows:
Sec. 23-2. Instructions and definitions.
A. An applicant for a competitive cable franchise ("Applicant") shall
include the requisite information set forth below, in writing, in its franchise
application, in addition to any information required by 47 CFR ~ 76.41 and
applicable state and local laws and the application fee set by resolution of the City
Council.
B. The City shall accept and review only those applications that include
complete responses to every requirement of Section 2 of this Ordinance.
Submission of an application that does not include the requisite information set
forth in Section 2 and the application fee shall not commence the time period for
granting or denying the application set forth in 47 C.F.R. ~76.41 (d). The Applicant
shall submit additional or updated information as necessary to ensure the requisite
information provided is complete and accurate for the City's review of the
application.
C. Applications shall be made to the Office of the City Manager.
D. Upon request, the City will promptly provide access to documents or
information in its possession or control that are necessary for the completion of
this application, provided that the Applicant does not otherwise have access to
such documents or information and that such documents or information are subject
to disclosure under Colorado open records laws.
E. For the purposes of the application, the terms, phrases, and their
derivations set forth below shall have the meanings given unless the context
indicates otherwise. When not consistent with the context, words used in the
present tense include the future tense, words in the plural number include the
singular number, and words in the singular include the plural number. The word
"shall" is always mandatory and not merely directory.
1 . "Affiliated Entity" or "Affiliate" means any entity having
ownership or control in common with the Grantee, in whole or in part,
including, without limitation, Grantee's Parent Corporations and any
subsidiaries or affiliates of such Parent Corporations.
-2-
2. "Applicant" means an applicant for a cable franchise pursuant
to the provisions of the Competitive Franchise Application Rule ("CFAR") set
forth in Part 76 of Title 47 of the Code of Federal Regulations, ~ 76.41, and
includes the Parent Corporation, its subsidiaries and Principals.
3. "City" means the City of Wheat Ridge, a Colorado home rule
municipality.
4. "Control" is not limited to majority stock ownership, but
includes actual working control in whatever manner exercised.
5. "Interest" includes officers, directors and shareholders owning
five percent (5%) or more of the Applicant's outstanding stock or any
equivalent voting interest of a partnership or joint venture.
6. "Parent Corporation" includes any entity with ownership or
control of the Applicant.
7. "Principal" includes any person, firm, corporation, partnership,
joint venture, affiliates, or other entity, who or which owns or controls five
percent or more of the voting stock (or any equivalent voting interest of a
partnership or joint venture) of the Applicant.
8. "Regulatory Authority" includes any governmental or quasi-
governmental organization or entity with jurisdiction over all or any portion
of the Applicant or its operations.
Sec. 23-3. Required information.
A. Identification and Ownership Information.
include:
The application shall
1. The name, address, telephone number and web site (if
applicable) of the Applicant and the proposed franchisee (if different from
Applicant); and
2. The name, address, primary telephone number and primary e-
mail address of all individual{s) authorized to represent the Applicant before
the City during its consideration of the franchise(s) requested, including the
Applicant's primary contact and any additional authorized contacts.
-3-
B. Business Structure.
1. If a corporation, the Applicant shall provide:
(a) A list all officers and members of the Board of Directors,
their principal affiliations and their addresses;
(b) A certificate of good standing indicating that the
Applicant is licensed to do business in the State of Colorado; and
(c) A statement indicating whether the Applicant is directly
or indirectly controlled by another corporation or legal entity. If so,
Applicant shall attach an explanatory statement and respond to
subsections 1 (a) and (b) above concerning the controlling corporation.
2. If a partnership, the Applicant shall:
(a) Describe the structure of the partnership and the
interests of general and limited partners; and
(b) State whether the Applicant is controlled directly or
indirectly by any corporation or other legal entity. If so, Applicant
shall attach an explanatory statement and respond to subsections 1 (a)
and (b), or 2(a) above, as applicable, concerning the controlling entity.
C. Experience.
1. Current Franchises. An Applicant shall list all cable systems in
which it or any Affiliate owns more than five percent of the system. For
each system Applicant shall include name of system, address, communities
served, number of subscribers, number of homes passed, date of system
award, duration (start and end date) of franchise, status of construction, and
percent of penetration of homes passed as of the most recent available date
(indicate date).
2. Potential Franchises. An Applicant shall list communities where
it or any Affiliate currently has a formal or informal request pending for an
initial franchise, the renewal of a franchise, or the approval of a transfer of
ownership. The Applicant shall include the name of communities, date of
application, and date of expected action.
-4-
D. Management Structure.
1. Every application for a competitive franchise shall include a
management/organizational chart, showing the management structure of the
Applicant. A similar chart shall also be provided showing the relationship of
the Applicant to all general partners, Parent Corporations, subsidiaries,
Affiliates and all other subsidiaries of Parent Corporations, including a brief
description of each entity's relationship to the Applicant.
Sec. 23-4. Legal qualifications.
A. Media Cross-Ownership.
1. Section 613 of the Cable Communications Policy Act of 1984,
47 U.S.C. ~533 (a), and applicable FCC rules prohibit certain forms of media
cross-ownership. An Applicant shall state whether it or an Affiliate directly
or indirectly owns, operates, controls or has an Interest in any of the
following, or whether the Applicant holds or operates any company or
business operating jointly with any of the following:
(a) A national broadcast television network (such as ABC,
CBS or NBC, etc.).
(b) A television broadcast station whose predicted Grade B
contour, computed in accordance with Section 73.684 of the FCC's
rules, overlaps in whole or in part the City's service area, or an
application for license to operate such a station.
(c) A telecommunications or telephone company whose
service area includes any portion of the City's service area.
2. If the response to any of Subsections (a) - (c) above is
affirmative, the Applicant shall state the name of the Applicant or Affiliate,
the nature and percentage of ownership or Interest and the company that is
owned or in which the Interest is held.
B. Franchise Violations.
1. An Applicant shall state whether it or any Affiliate has been
found in violation by a Regulatory Authority or franchising authority of any
-5-
franchise ordinance or agreement, contract or regulation governing a cable
system. If so, the Applicant shall identify the judicial or administrative
proceeding, giving the date, name of tribunal and result or disposition of that
proceeding.
C. Other Violations.
1. An Applicant shall state whether it has been found in violation
by a Regulatory Authority of any other type (e.g. utility) of franchise,
ordinance, agreement, permit, contract or regulation. If so, the Applicant
shall identify the judicial or administrative proceeding, giving the date, name
of tribunal and result or disposition of that proceeding.
Sec. 23-5. Financial qualifications.
A. Unless SEC Forms 10K and 100 are available on the EDGAR
database, Applicants with existing operations shall provide audited financial
statements, including statements of income, balance sheets and cash flow
statements, together with any notes necessary to the understanding of the
financial statements for the last three fiscal years for the Applicant and any Parent
Corporation.
B. Applicants that are new (start-up) entities shall provide pro forma
projections for the next five fiscal years, if available, but at a minimum the next
three fiscal years from the date of the application.
Sec. 23-6. Technical qualifications, planned services and operations.
A. The application shall describe the Applicant's planned initial and
proposed cable services geographic area, including a map of all areas proposed to
be served and proposed dates for offering service to each area. The application
shall additionally state whether the Applicant proposes to provide cable services to
the entire franchise area, and if so, a proposed timetable for meeting that goal.
B. If the Applicant has or asserts existing authority to access the public
right of way in any of the initial or proposed service areas listed in Section 5.A
above, the Applicant shall state the basis for such authority or asserted authority
and attach the relevant agreements or other documentation of such authority.
C. The Applicant shall describe with particularity its planned residential
Cable services, including basic cable services, other cable programming service
-6-
tiers, and any additional pay-per-view, on-demand or digital services; and the
projected rates for each category or tier or service.
D. The Applicant shall describe with particularity its planned system
technical design, upstream and downstream capacity and speed, provision for
analog or digital services or packages, distribution of fiber, planned count of
households per residential node, and any other information necessary to
demonstrate that the Applicant's technology will be deployed so as to be able to
successfully offer cable services in the proposed locations.
E. The Applicant shall describe with particularity its planned non-
residential cable services.
F. The Applicant shall describe its planned construction and extension or
phase schedule, as applicable, including system extension plans or policy; and
describe the current status of the Applicant's existing or proposed arrangements
with area utilities, including pole attachments, vault, or conduit sharing agreements
as applicable.
G. The Applicant shall describe its plan to ensure that the safety,
functioning and appearance of property and convenience and safety of other
persons not be adversely affected by installation or construction of the Applicant's
facilities, and that property owners are justly compensated for any damages
caused by the installation, construction, operation or removal of the facilities.
H. The Applicant shall describe its plan to comply with the subscriber
privacy protections set forth in 47 U.S.C. ~551, and the privacy protections of the
City's local cable customer service standards.
Sec. 23-7 Affidavit of applicant.
A. Each application shall be accompanied by an affidavit substantially in
the form set forth below:
This application is submitted by the undersigned who has been
duly authorized to make the representations within on behalf
of the Applicant and certifies the representations are true and
correct.
The Applicant recognizes that all representations are binding
on it, that all application commitments are enforceable, and
-7-
that material misrepresentations or omissions, or failure to
adhere to any such representation may result in a denial of an
application by the City.
The Applicant shall comply with all applicable local laws.
Consent is hereby given to the City, and its representatives to
make inquiry into the legal, character, technical, financial and
other qualifications of the Applicant by contacting any persons
or organizations named herein as references, or by any other
appropriate means.
Name of Applicant's Authorized Representative:
Affiant's Signature:
Official Position:
Date:
STATE OF COLORADO )
) ss.
COUNTY OF )
Subscribed and sworn to before me this
2007.
day of
Witness my hand and official seal.
My Commission expires:
Notary Public
Sec. 23-8. Open records and confidentiality.
A. Unless otherwise provided by law, information submitted as part of an
application is open to public inspection and subject to the Colorado Open Records
Act. It is the Applicant's responsibility to be familiar with the Colorado Open
Records Act. An Applicant may specifically identify any information it considers
proprietary. In the event that the City receives a request from another party to
disclose any information which the Applicant has deemed proprietary, the City will
-8-
tender to the Applicant the defense of any request to compel disclosure. By
submitting information which the Applicant deems proprietary or otherwise exempt
from disclosure, the Applicant agrees to defend and hold harmless the City from
any claim for disclosure including but not limited to any expenses including out-of-
pocket costs and attorneys' fees, as well as any judgment entered against the City
for the attorney fees of the party requesting disclosure.
Sec. 23-9. Application fee.
The City Council hereby sets the application fee to cover the reasonable cost
of processing applications under this Article at $2,000 per application, payable at
time of application. The Council may amend this fee amount in the future by
resolution. Upon request of the Applicant, the City may reduce or waive the
application fee. In evaluating such a request, the City will consider the following
factors: (1) the size of the proposed franchise area; (2) the number of potential
subscribers in the proposed franchise area; (3) the financial hardship to the
Applicant (including any parent corporation or affiliate); and (4) other information
relevant to the cost of processing the application and/or the Applicant's ability to
pay the fee.
Sec. 23-10. Review process.
A. Acceptance of Application.
1. Within five business days of receipt of an application, the City
shall review the application to ensure that all requisite information is
included in the application.
2. If the application is not complete, the City will notify the
Applicant in writing, listing the requisite information that is required to
complete the application and notifying the Applicant the that time period for
granting or denying the application set forth in 47 C.F.R. ~ 76.41 (d) will not
begin to run until such information is received.
3. If the application is complete, the City will notify the Applicant
in writing that all requisite information has been received.
B. Staff Review. The City staff shall review all completed applications
based on the review criteria set forth herein. If, during the review of an
application, staff reasonably requires additional information from the Applicant,
staff will promptly request the information from the Applicant, in writing, along
-9-
with a notification that the time period for granting or denying the application set
forth in 47 C.F.R. ~ 76.41 (d) will be tolled until such information is received by the
City. After completing the review, staff shall provide an analysis of the application
to the City Council.
C. Franchise Negotiations. Within the time period set forth in 47 C.F .R.
~ 76.41 (d), the City shall attempt to negotiate a cable franchise agreement with
the Applicant, and within that time period, schedule the application and any
proposed franchise for public hearing as set forth in Section 23-11.
Sec. 23-11. Public hearing.
The City shall hold a public hearing before acting on the application,
affording participants a process substantially equivalent to that required by 47
U.S.C. ~546(c)(2) governing renewal of cable franchises.
Sec. 23-12. Review criteria.
The City may deny an application based on the information provided in the
application, at the public hearing and/or any terms of a proposed franchise
agreement, if:
A. The Applicant does not have the financial, technical, or legal
qualifications to provide cable service;
B. The Applicant will not provide adequate public, educational, and
governmental access channel capacity, facilities, or financial support; or
C. The Applicant's proposed terms do not comply with applicable federal,
state and local laws and regulations including, but not limited to, local customer
service standards, or relevant existing contractual obligations of the City.
Sec. 23-13. Non-CFAR franchise applications.
Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Ordinance, any competitive
cable services franchise Applicant may elect to submit a cable franchise application
to the City and/or engage in cable franchise negotiations without regard to the
application of the FCC CFAR. In such cases, the City will negotiate the terms of a
competitive cable franchise without regard to 47 CFR ~76.41 and the other
provisions of this Ordinance. Agreement by any Applicant to negotiate a franchise
without regard to 47 CFR ~ 76.41 and the other provisions of this Ordinance shall
-10-
not be deemed by the City to effect a waiver of any Applicant's right under
applicable law to trigger application of 47 CFR ~ 76.41 and this Ordinance, where
applicable.
Section 2. Severabilitv: Conflicting Ordinances Reoealed. If any section,
subsection or clause of this Ordinance shall be deemed to be unconstitutional or
otherwise invalid, the validity of the remaining sections, subsections and clauses
shall not be affected thereby. All other ordinances or parts of ordinances in
conflict with the provisions of this Ordinance are hereby repealed
Section 3. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be in full force and effect upon
signature by the Mayor, as permitted by Section 5.11 of the Charter.
READ, ADOPTED AND ORDERED PUBLISHED on second and final reading by
a vote of 8 to 0, this 11 th day of June, 2007, ordered published in full in a
newspaper of general circulation in the City of Wheat Ridge and Public Hearing and
consideration on final passage set for June 25, 2007, at 7:00 o'clock p.m., in the
Council Chambers, 7500 West 29th Avenue, Wheat Ridge, Colorado
READ, ADOPTED AND ORDERED PUBLISHED on second and final reading by
a vote of 8 to 0, this 25th day of June, 2007.
SIGNED by the Mayor on this 25thday of June
,2007
-ill,'" \~'\'\~\1 ) \\c>.IJ v ~,
Jerry DiTullio, Mayo~
--,.,
lyW
ATTEST:
~-"'.." ~ ~ I'
\ \ ' \ \ \
" 0(\ .n:'-. \ G 'I'.f::j" \ ~'-.J >~"J,)\ \-(J\
Michael Snow, dity Clerk \ )
\
,
d E. Dahl, City A-ttorney
-11-
First Publication: 6-14-2007
Second Publication: June 28, 2007
Wheat Ridge Transcript:
Effective Date: June 25, 2007
-12-